Handcrafted Italian flavors, a legendary meatball wheel, and a wine bar worth the trip to Gray Street.
There's a dish at The Sicilian Butcher that regulars talk about before they even sit down: the Meatball Ferris Wheel. It arrives at the table like a centerpiece, stacked and sauced and completely unlike anything else on a Nashville menu. That single creation tells you everything about how this kitchen thinks: go big, go specific, and make it memorable.
The restaurant earns its 4.8-star rating across more than a thousand reviews not through hype but through repetition of real quality. The garlic bread is the kind guests describe as the softest they've ever had. The meatballs draw comparisons that run out of words. The service, led by a staff that genuinely trains with care, turns first-time visitors into regulars before the check arrives.
Situated at 475 Gray St in Nashville's booming Midtown corridor, The Sicilian Butcher blends the warmth of a family table with the style of a proper Italian wine bar. You can come for a quick lunch, linger over a long dinner with a Sicilian red, or grab pastries and desserts on your way out. The kitchen runs seven days a week, opening at 11 AM every day so the craving never has to wait.
The menu spans the full Italian experience without losing focus. Housemade meatballs anchor the savory side, available in formats that range from casual to theatrical. Wood-fired pizzas come loaded with authentic toppings, and the seafood selections bring coastal Sicily to a landlocked Tennessee address. Every plate is built around scratch ingredients and old-world technique.
Beyond the kitchen, the wine bar offers a curated list of Italian and international bottles that pair naturally with the food. Craft cocktails round out the bar program for guests who prefer something mixed. When dinner ends, the pastry and dessert counter keeps things going with cannoli, confections, and baked goods that make leaving harder than it should be.
Takeout orders are available for guests who want the full Sicilian Butcher experience at home. Whether you're feeding the family on a Tuesday or planning a special Friday night out, the kitchen is ready from 11 AM to 10:30 PM on weekends and 10 PM through the week.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
You'll find us at 475 Gray St, Suite 101, Nashville, TN 37203, in the Midtown area. Plenty of street and lot parking options are nearby.
We're open Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:30 PM. We are open all seven days of the week.
It's our signature dish: a dramatic, multi-tiered presentation of housemade meatballs served with sauce. Guests consistently call it the highlight of their visit, and it's absolutely worth ordering.
Yes. You can place takeout orders to enjoy the full Sicilian Butcher menu at home. Visit our website at locations.thesicilianbutcher.com to explore ordering options for the Nashville location.
Absolutely. The atmosphere is stylish and the wine bar adds a romantic touch. The attentive service and standout dishes make it a go-to for anniversaries, date nights, and celebratory dinners.
Yes. The Sicilian Butcher features a pastry and dessert selection including Italian confections that are made to finish the meal right. It's also a great reason to linger a little longer.
Very much so. The warm, welcoming atmosphere works for families, groups, couples, and solo diners alike. The broad menu means there's something for everyone at the table.
Real neighbors nearby, each with their own site. Tap any one to visit it directly.
1604 8th Ave S Ste 330, Nashville, TN 37203, USA
818 3rd Ave S, Nashville, TN 37210, USA
2106 8th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37204, USA
623 7th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37203, USA
407 11th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37203, USA
Other family restaurant spots near here. Tap one to open its page.